But my question here is: Why does everyone think its either Theo or John or them combined who bacame the New Prince? I just thought Theo was the New Prince, for all he was wearing was John's clothing... He never had the idol(The Soul) or anything... Im probaly missing something, but I can't just seem to see how it might be John DeFoe. :/ I didn't think John took Theo over...
I agree with you. The whole point of the Bridge is that John DeFoe has to be completely, utterly, and totally destroyed for the Bridge to be created. Since he was destroyed so horribly (horribly, I say), there's no way that John DeFoe has any part of the New Prince. It's simply Theo (who happened to be wearing John DeFoe's garments) getting Cabadath's power zapped into him.
One of the things that just really bothered me about this game is the creation of the New Prince. I get why he has to be made (complete the cycle) but we'll never know what he's capable of. The only times we see him are when he's floating around, finishing off Cabadath or blocking a passageway. I also kind of feel like Somerset/The Caretaker is a deus ex machina. Not to say that Yahtzee wrote himself into a corner... it's just that he randomly appears in the last game and ties all the details together.
I should content myself by knowing that yes, he did indeed tie all the details together.