QUOTE (Storm @ Jun 10 2005, 02:07 PM)
I'm just waiting for a good explanation as to why Luke's whiny bitch scream of "That's not true! That's impossible! Nooooooooo! Nooooo!" in ESB is more acceptable than Vader's "Nooooo!" in ROTS.
I have always laughed at that part in ESB, even as a kid. But don't get me wrong, I do like the scene and I think ESB is the best movie in the saga. I just like laughing at how pathetic Luke is.
I have to admit you have a point Storm. People who aren't fans of Star Wars make fun of that part. Taken alone Luke's "Nooooooooooo" does sound cheesy and over the top. But, as it has been said, that is Luke's character. Add to the fact Vader carries that scene with JEJ's delivery and well done lines. The whole scene is very effective when you take everything into account
I guess most, including myself, wanted to see a diffrent reaction from Vader. We've already seen the weak and vunerable Anakin throughout the last two movies, the first time we see Vader we want it to be badass. Perhaps our expectations were too high