How did lava become canonical? Anakin's fall
#1
Posted 03 June 2005 - 10:49 AM
Why?
The more I think about it, the more ludicrous the idea seems to me. It's way, way over the top, especially in the prequels where we're asked to believe that, while in all other scenes Anakin's Force ability doesn't seem to be anything special, in this one particular scene his strength with the Force is so extraordinary that it can defy physics and chemistry and prevent him from instant carbonisation in molten rock.
Whose goofy idea was this in the first place? There are so many better and credible ways that Anakin could have been disfigured.
#2
Posted 03 June 2005 - 11:17 AM
Anakin and his ending up in molten lava. Even in a galaxy far, far away this isn't very realistic. But by ROTJ realism wasn't exactly high on Lucas's list of priorities
This post has been edited by Michel Orla: 03 June 2005 - 11:21 AM
#4
Posted 03 June 2005 - 12:13 PM
Anakin and his ending up in molten lava. Even in a galaxy far, far away this isn't very realistic. But by ROTJ realism wasn't exactly high on Lucas's list of priorities
I think it goes back even further than that.
I seem to recall that even around the time of The Empire Strikes Back, Lucas was mentioning it in interviews.
This post has been edited by Devout Catalyst: 03 June 2005 - 12:14 PM
#5
Posted 03 June 2005 - 12:23 PM
Anakin and his ending up in molten lava. Even in a galaxy far, far away this isn't very realistic. But by ROTJ realism wasn't exactly high on Lucas's list of priorities
In the version of the novel that I have, when Darth Vader is dying, he is thinking about his bad memories, and he "pushes aside" the memory of lava creeping up his back (which didn't happen in the movie).
I was expecting Anakin to lose his limbs in the lava, but I think the amputation is more realistic (since if Anakin hits the lava, he would probably die, not just lose limbs). Also, in the movie, I don't think he ever actually touches the lava much; one of his leg caps touches it and begins to catch the rest of his body on fire.
Is that right?
#6
Posted 03 June 2005 - 01:00 PM
I had two ideas of how Vader wound up in the suit. The first was over the course of several fights, he gets one bad wound here, loses one limb there, and each time gets a mechanical limb, or respirator, or whatever. Eventually Vader himself decides that he might as well encase his entire body in armor, with a life support system, at least it looks intimidating and it gives him more protection.
My second idea has Anakin getting badly wounded in one fight, though as in the actual prequels he could have one artificial limb already. but unlike in the actual prequels I would have the audience actually think he is dead. Then in Episode IV Vader appears. And he doesn't get his limbs hacked off like the Monty Python Black Night, his worst injury does something to his lungs and he needs to encase his chest in a breathing machine. He has lost a limb already, so again why not go whole hog and just wear the black armor all the time. Maybe his hearing is damaged and he needs the helmet to hear properly.
And the Emperor, well he always looks like that. Or his look is the natural result of using the Dark Side to live to hundreds of years. I'll add that the ROTJ Emperor was mostly hidden in his robes and mainly looked really, really aged, not like a monster.
There is nothing that says the Emperor has to be human either, obviously Vader does once its revealed that he has human progeny.
#7
Posted 03 June 2005 - 02:02 PM
This is what my brother and I had thought, too, why he wears the suit. We thought that the Emp' sends him out to (as Obi-Wan says in ANH) to "hunt down and destroy the Jedi," through his multiple battles, he gains injuries, slowly replacing limbs with bionic parts as he goes along. I figured the ANH Vader was the final form for him. I would've liked to have seen him in stages, but... alas... not to be.
Battle for the Galaxy--read the "other Star Wars"
All I know is I haven't seen the real prequels yet.
#8
Posted 03 June 2005 - 03:05 PM
As for the lava thing, I liked that scene, and I think that Ewan's performance there makes his actions understandable, especially the last line, "You were my brother Anakin. I loved you." Right there Anakin catches on fire. What's Obi-Wan going to do? Can he kill his former pupil and friend, who is defenseless, in cold blood? Can he save Anakin from the fire, after he's killed younglings and probably other Jedi in cold blood? He cannot do either of those things. Perhaps he knew Anakin would live, perhaps he thought Anakin would die, we dont' know. But we do know that he just couldn't bring himself right there, seeing this pathetic, limbless lifeform who used to be this cute little boy and (supposedly) compassionate Jedi, to chop Anakin's head off, or stab him, or whatever he would've done. But he also realized that he couldn't help Anakin. I thought it was a really well done, poignent scene with Ewan's best acting of the movie.
Also, though I agree that the original concept of Anakin falling into lava was unrealistic, I thought the way they did it in the movie made up for that. He never really falls in, he just catches fire and the fire spreads and burns his body. And I'm pretty sure the ROTJ book only introduced the concept of Anakin having some contact with lava (I don't think it ever says he falls in though) because it had been assumed previous to the novel.
And are you saying it was wrong to kill Palpatine there? This is the embodiment of evil. Windu knows this. Windu knows he has control of the government, that he will be acquitted in a trial, and will spread darkness throughout the galaxy (the moment's made much better if you've read Shatterpoint, because you know that Windu sees a huge shatterpoint in Palpatine and knows that this time he must take advantage of it, as he couldn't with Dooku). Anakin only sees Windu about to kill what he thinks is a defenseless Palpatine, and remembering what he did with Dooku doesn't want the same thing to happen, thinks it's wrong. Therefore, in the situation, I'd say both were right, and as we see later and as Windu knew, Palpatine certainly wasn't defenseless.
#9
Posted 03 June 2005 - 03:31 PM
That's from the novel. Maybe this was told from Obi Wans "point of view" again. Because he neither tries to turn him back, nor does Anakin fall into any molten pit.
But if you go by the movies thats never mentioned, so Im assuming Lucas was going by that and not the novels. Either way Anakin's physical transformation is well done, and it was a good move NOT to show him fall into a molten pit, no matter how strong he was in the force
#10
Posted 03 June 2005 - 05:22 PM
And yeah, like I said, falling into the pit was just way too unrealistic. This was much better.
But I gotta read the ROTJ novel again. Despite the stupidity of the idea, the writing in that seemed good, and I do remember I loved how he wrote the Darth Vader death scene.
#11
Posted 03 June 2005 - 08:00 PM
#12
Posted 03 June 2005 - 09:58 PM
In one explanation of that scene to myself I had the idea that the pit, though molten-hot, was actually a volcanic water spring, filled with light and steam and sulphurous smoke and perfectly capable of killing anyone who fell in there. I didn't mind having his robe fall in lava and his clothing catch fire and burn around him as in ROTS, but I've got a different idea for how Anakin dies and Vader is created these days.
The ROTJ novel was actually quite enjoyable, while the other two were fairly simple, largely because they didn't have the same ponderous mass of editing that ROTJ demanded.
#13
Posted 05 June 2005 - 07:57 PM
it says 'molten pit' i'm quite sure...
but yeah, their proximity to molten lava in such quantity was almost as dumb as naboo having a river run through the planet core...
it seems that basic science is beyond the 'king of sci-fi'
Also: The Chefelf.com Lord of the Rings | RoBUTZ (a primative webcomic) | KOTOR 1 NPC profiles |
Music: HYPOID (industrial rock) | Spectrox Toxemia (Death Metal) | Cannibalingus (80s style thrash metal) | Wasabi Nose Bleed (Exp.Techno) | DeadfeeD (Exp.Ambient) |||(more to come)
#14
Posted 05 June 2005 - 10:17 PM
I mean sure, it looks BAD ASS, but what would make the emperor think "YES, it will be your home!" to the idea of that crazy space-nazi helmet that looks like the front of an 18-wheeler? I just think it's hilarious that they just gave him THAT helmet after the battle
This post has been edited by Darth Borba: 05 June 2005 - 10:18 PM
#15
Posted 06 June 2005 - 10:42 AM
This is how I had imagined it to be (silly me), but I thought there was a Republic, and they had troops, and I thought that the Empire eventually corporated some Republic designs and styles in its overtake of the military, i.e., look at the Death Star Gunners, and some of the personel hanging around.. their helmets are very Vader-like!
I thought we might see a lot more Republic troopers (of course, I thought there would be Republic troops in the PT, but silly me, guess not), and eventually, this helmet style would be placed on Vader, and become a general in time (because he is a general in ANH).
If Anakin was to be cyborgized in anyway--in accordance to PT-logic---he ought to look more like General Grievous, right?
Battle for the Galaxy--read the "other Star Wars"
All I know is I haven't seen the real prequels yet.